I have 3 cards, CIBC Aeroplan, TD First Class Travel and RBC WJWE and have status with both major airlines. WJ "used to" treat their "status-ed" customers with some perks. Today, even with gold status and flying business, I still get treated like dirt, zero percent on time performance, consistently out of food/drinks on the plane, still waiting for a lounge in Edmonton etc. Last time I had to make a last minute flight change, the attitude I got over the phone, almost unbearable. I flew WJ twice last week, one flight delayed 3 times, zero apologies. I keep the WJWE card only for the companion voucher and because it is a MC not a Visa. The companion voucher is not really a great perk consider the fees you have to pay to use it (almost same price as an economy ticket); used to be great when the fees were nominal. The voucher is only good if you are flying business class on long haul flights to Europe or something but it is almost impossible to book a business class voucher flight on long hauls, those seats get booked up superquick.
At least AC treats their business class customers or customers with status with some respect. I tried hard using WJ as my primary airline for a year, but I am back to flying AC exclusively unless WJ has a direct flight like YEG-LAS which AC does not have.
TD FCTravel is good ONLY if you like being in the Expedia enviroment, points worth a more if using TDExpedia BUT prices are always higher if you use TDExpedia and certain hotels are off the list etc. etc. One time I had two computers side by side, one TDExpedia and one normal Expedia, prices and selections are slightly different. I tried hard to make TDExpedia work for me for 2 years then I gave up; simply don't like the restrictions TDExpedia place on me. So started in 2024, got the CIBC Aeroplan back and it is my primary card again.
For people who don't travel much, I would suggest the TD FCTravel, you are not likely to notice the TDExpedia restrictions or price bumps. Also, if you are flying economy, the free checked bags perk is good with both WJWE and Aeroplan cards.
Flyertalk is a good forum if you want to bitch about airlines.
Never had Scotia Passport, will have to look into it.